MEMA Guides / Financial crime

Business-wide risk assessment under MLR 2017

What regulation 18 requires, which risk factors to cover, how to score inherent and residual risk, how to link it to your controls, and how often to review it.

  • HighNRA 2025 rating for money laundering risk in EMIs and PSPs, up from mediumSource
  • 5groups of risk factor in regulation 18(2)(b)Source
  • 30 June 2026when most of the Treasury's 2026 MLR changes took effectSource
  • Yearlyminimum report to senior management by an EMI or PSP's appointed individualSource

The guide in 30 seconds

Practical guidance
  1. 01Write about your businessThe FCA found few firms tailor the assessment. Use your own data, products and corridors.
  2. 02Score before and after controlsShow inherent risk, control strength and residual risk, with evidence for every control rating.
  3. 03Make it change somethingLink every high residual risk to a control, an owner and a date, and take it to senior management.

Explore the chapters

Read them in order, or jump to the one you need.

Chapter 01 · The starting point

What the law and the FCA require

Regulation 18 says you must identify and assess the money laundering risks your business faces, and keep a written record. The FCA has found that most firms do it badly.

3 min read · 2 sections

Translucent cobalt and lime glass gavel resting on a round glass block, set on a sunny white concrete terrace above a blue bay

A business-wide risk assessment (BWRA) is the document that records how your firm has identified and assessed the money laundering and terrorist financing risks its business faces. Regulation 18 of the Money Laundering Regulations 2017 (MLR 2017) requires every relevant person to "take appropriate steps to identify and assess the risks" of money laundering and terrorist financing. The MLRs apply to all payment service providers and e-money issuers (Approach Document 12.20).

High
is the National Risk Assessment 2025 rating for money laundering risk in the e-money and payments sector
The NRA says the rating rose from medium to high.
5
groups of risk factor named in regulation 18(2)(b)
Customers, countries, products or services, transactions and delivery channels.
30 June 2026
is when most of the Treasury's 2026 changes to the MLRs took effect
The changes are in SI 2026/621. Regulation 18 itself was not rewritten.

The FCA is the supervisor for e-money institutions, for authorised payment institutions other than those with permission for money remittance only, and for registered account information service providers. HMRC supervises payment institutions that only provide money remittance, and may supervise those that provide it alongside other services (Approach Document 12.22 and 12.23). If HMRC supervises you, the legal duty is the same, but the guidance you follow is HMRC's.

What the rules ask of you, in plain English
RuleIn plain English
MLR 2017 reg 18(1)Take appropriate steps to identify and assess the money laundering and terrorist financing risks your business faces.
Reg 18(2)Take account of information your supervisor gives you, and of risk factors for your customers, the countries you operate in, your products or services, your transactions and your delivery channels.
Reg 18(3)Make the steps fit the size and nature of your business.
Reg 18(4)Keep an up-to-date record in writing of the steps you took, unless your supervisor tells you in writing that no record is needed.
Reg 18(6)On request, give your supervisor the assessment, the information it was based on, and the record.
Reg 18ADo the same for proliferation financing, with its own written record.
Reg 19(1) and (2)Set up policies, controls and procedures that address the risks you identified, review them regularly, and have senior management approve them.
Reg 21(7)E-money issuers and payment service providers must appoint an individual to monitor compliance with those policies and to tell senior management how well they work at least once a year.

Business-wide and customer risk assessments

Business-wide risk assessment

  • Covers the whole business.
  • Looks at customers, countries, products, transactions and channels as groups.
  • Is approved by senior management and reviewed on a cycle.
  • Drives your policies, controls and risk appetite.

Customer risk assessment

  • Covers one customer or relationship.
  • Sets the level of due diligence for that customer.
  • Builds on the business-wide assessment.
  • Can inform the BWRA, but in the words of FCG 2.2.4 "is not a substitute for" it.
Up next · Chapter 2The risk factors to consider

Chapter 02 · Identifying the risks

The risk factors to consider

Regulation 18(2) gives you five groups of risk factor. The FCA found that few firms tailor them to their own business, so the examples you pick matter more than the headings.

3 min read · 2 sections

Translucent cobalt and lime glass sculpture of a payment card with a glowing tick, ringed by curved arrows, on a sunny white terrace above a bay

The FCA reviewed business-wide risk assessments at building societies, platforms, custody firms, payments and e-money firms and wealth managers, and published its findings on 11 November 2025. Its headline was: "Most firms we reviewed have a BWRA, but few are identifying relevant risks and tailoring the BWRA to the specific business." The FCA said some assessments focused on "fraud or generic risks" and left out money laundering, sanctions, bribery, proliferation and terrorist financing.

The five groups in regulation 18(2)(b), and what to ask

  • Customers

    Who are they? Businesses or individuals, how complex the ownership is, politically exposed persons, cash-intensive businesses, and customers who give false or stolen identification (reg 33(6)(a)).

  • Countries or areas

    Where do customers sit, and where does money go? Weak AML systems, corruption, sanctions, terrorist financing and FATF call for action countries (reg 33(6)(c)).

  • Products or services

    Pre-paid cards, virtual IBANs, cross-border payments, remittance, merchant acquiring, open banking, new products and anything that might favour anonymity (reg 33(6)(b)).

  • Transactions

    Size, speed and patterns, third-party funding, and payments with no apparent economic or legal purpose (reg 33(1)(f)).

  • Delivery channels

    Non-face-to-face onboarding, agents and distributors, introducers, and checks that a third party carries out for you (reg 33(6)(b)).

Regulation 18(2)(a) also tells you to take account of information from your supervisor. In practice that means the FCA's findings and portfolio letters, together with the Treasury's national risk assessment. The NRA 2025 gives a sector view for e-money institutions and payment service providers. Use it as a prompt, then test each point against your own data.

Payments risk drivers in the NRA 2025
DriverWhat the NRA saysA question to ask
Scale and cross-border reachThe sector's risk rose from medium to high because of rapid scaling, more complex and varied services, and more exposure to high risk jurisdictions (5.64).How much of our value goes abroad, and to where?
Simple onboardingEMIs and PSPs may have simpler onboarding than high street banks, with no physical presence needed (5.66).How fast can a new customer open an account, and what stops a false identity?
AgentsWhere an agent brings a customer, the agent often does the checks. This may not be as robust. The EMI or PSP keeps responsibility (5.67).How many customers come through agents, and who tests their checks?
OutsourcingOutsourcing AML functions can create weaknesses. The firm remains responsible and the responsibility "cannot be delegated" (5.68).Which checks do vendors run, and how do we know they work?
Pre-paid cardsThe risk remains high. Cards can be used cross-border and some allow cash withdrawals (5.73).What limits and monitoring do our cards have?
Virtual IBANsMultiple virtual IBANs can reduce visibility of end users and transactions (5.74).Do we see the end users behind each virtual account?
Fraud and mulesFraud is the most commonly experienced crime in the UK, over 43% of crime in England and Wales (3.8). Business accounts are increasingly targeted by money mules and are now 1 in 5 cases reported to Cifas (5.14).How do we spot mule accounts early, including on business accounts?

Where to find your inputs

  • Customer data: counts by type, country, tenure, ownership complexity and risk rating.
  • Product and channel data: share of customers and value by product, agent and introducer.
  • Transaction data: cross-border share, corridors, third-party funding and velocity.
  • Monitoring and reporting: alerts, case outcomes and internal and external suspicious activity reports.
  • Sanctions and screening: alert volumes, backlog, true hits and false positives.
  • Testing and audit: compliance monitoring results, internal audit and any regulator findings.
  • External: the NRA 2025, FCA findings and letters, and the FATF call for action list.
  • Change: products, markets, channels, vendors or partners planned for the next 12 months.
Up next · Chapter 3Scoring the risks: inherent, controls and residual

Chapter 03 · The method

Scoring the risks: inherent, controls and residual

The law does not set a scoring method. Use one that is simple, written down and the same every year, and score the risk before and after your controls.

4 min read · 7 sections

Translucent cobalt, lime and mint glass sculpture of fanned pages wrapped by a curving arrow, set on a sunny white terrace above a bay under a clear sky

The MLRs do not prescribe how to score. The FCA's November 2025 findings describe good practice instead. Assessments were quantitative and qualitative, took in internal and external factors and were weighted. They considered inherent risks, control effectiveness and residual risks. They were documented in detail, with changes to the methodology logged and approved. Poor practice included assessments that were solely qualitative, and firms that concluded they were low risk, or that controls were effective, without evidence.

The method in our template, in five steps

  1. List the risks

    For each of the five groups, list the factors that apply to you. The payments edition of our template starts with 32.

  2. Score the inherent risk

    Rate each factor for likelihood and impact, each from 1 to 5. The score is likelihood times impact, so the highest is 25.

  3. Roll up to the group

    A group's score is half the average of its factor scores plus half the highest, so one severe factor is not diluted by many low ones.

  4. Rate the controls

    Rate each control for design and for how well it operates, each from 0 to 4. Its strength is the lower of the two, as a share of 4. Rate it "strong" only with evidence, such as testing results.

  5. Work out the residual risk

    Residual risk is the group score multiplied by one minus 75% of the average strength of the controls that mitigate it. The 75% cap means that even perfect controls cannot take the risk to zero.

The scales in our template
ScoreLikelihoodImpact
1Rare: could occur only in exceptional circumstancesMinimal: negligible harm, contained by routine controls
2Unlikely: not expected, but possibleMinor: limited harm, small number of transactions or customers
3Possible: some exposure in our customer or product baseModerate: meaningful financial crime or regulatory attention
4Likely: clear exposure in our businessMajor: significant criminal funds moved, supervisory intervention likely
5Almost certain: material, ongoing exposureSevere: systemic facilitation of crime, threat to the authorisation

Worked example: Brindlemoor Pay

Brindlemoor Pay: scoring the delivery channels group
FactorLikelihoodImpactScore
Non-face-to-face relationships without safeguards4312
Outsourcing and third-party delivery3412
AI-enabled document fraud and identity circumvention4416
Simple, fully remote onboarding relative to banks4312
Customers brought by agents and distributors3412

The five scores average 12.8 and the highest is 16, so the group's inherent score is 0.5 x 12.8 + 0.5 x 16 = 14.4, which is High. Seven controls mitigate this group. Their strengths are 0.75, 0.75, 0.75, 0.5, 0.5, 0.5 and 0.5, an average of 0.607. The mitigation is 0.75 x 0.607 = 0.455, so the residual score is 14.4 x (1 - 0.455) = 7.84, which is Medium. Brindlemoor's appetite for this group is Low, so it is above appetite.

Brindlemoor Pay: inherent and residual score by group
Customers, inherent12.6 score
Customers, residual6.8 score
Countries, inherent12.9 score
Countries, residual7.7 score
Products, inherent10.8 score
Products, residual6.1 score
Transactions, inherent13.7 score
Transactions, residual7.7 score
Channels, inherent14.4 score
Channels, residual7.8 score

Top of the Medium band: 10 score

Controls bring every group down from High to Medium. Countries and channels are above the firm's Low appetite, so they need action. Overall the firm's inherent score is 12.88 and its residual score is 7.23.

Illustrative example Not FCA figures. Use your own.

Brindlemoor Pay: the five highest-scoring factors
FactorGroupLIScore
AI-enabled document fraud and identity circumventionDelivery channels4416, Very high
Unusual or excessively complex ownership structuresCustomers4416, Very high
Cross-border movement of fundsTransactions4416, Very high
Fraud proceeds and mule activityTransactions4416, Very high
Countries subject to sanctions or embargoesCountries3515, High
Up next · Chapter 4Linking the assessment to your policies and controls

Chapter 05 · Keeping it alive

How often to review it, and who signs it off

The law says keep it up to date, not how often. Review it at least yearly and whenever something material changes, and keep the evidence.

3 min read · 3 sections

Translucent blue and lime glass sculpture on a sunlit white concrete terrace above a bay, illustrating authorisation

Regulation 18(4) requires an "up-to-date record in writing" of the steps you took, but it sets no fixed interval. The FCA says that "as risks change over time, you need to keep your risk assessment up to date". FCG 2.2.4 asks firms to "regularly review" both business-wide and individual risk assessments. The FCA's good practice example was a firm that formally assessed its BWRA yearly, "rather than simply refresh". For e-money issuers and payment service providers, regulation 21(7) also requires the appointed individual to report to senior management at least yearly.

A yearly cycle (illustrative)

  1. Month 1
    Gather
    Pull the data from the checklist: customers, products, transactions, alerts, testing and external sources.
  2. Month 2
    Score
    Business areas score their risks and controls. The MLRO consolidates and checks for consistency.
  3. Month 3
    Challenge
    Compliance, product and operations challenge the scores. Internal audit or another independent function tests a sample.
  4. Month 4
    Approve
    The board or a delegated committee reviews the document and a short summary, and minutes the decision.
  5. Months 5 to 12
    Act and report
    Track the actions. Report progress with the regulation 21(7) update. Test the highest residual risks first.
  6. Any time
    Off-cycle review
    Review the affected part when a trigger below occurs, and record the version and the reason.

Triggers for an off-cycle review

  • New product or channel

    Review before launch. Regulation 19(4)(c) expects risks to be assessed before and while you adopt new products or technology.

  • New market or corridor

    A new country, partner or payment corridor changes the geographic and transaction risk.

  • A new national risk assessment

    Record how it changed your scoring.

  • Supervisor findings or letters

    Reg 18(2)(a) tells you to take account of what the FCA tells you.

  • An incident or finding

    A fraud event, a failed audit or a regulator question shows where scores were wrong.

  • A change in business model

    Ownership, outsourcing, volumes or customer mix change the profile.

Who owns what

  • Board and senior management

    Approve the assessment and the risk appetite, challenge the scores, and minute the discussion.

  • MLRO or nominated officer

    Owns the document and the method, and consolidates the scores. Often the individual appointed under reg 21(7).

  • Compliance

    Tests the controls, checks the evidence behind each rating, and maintains the action log.

  • Product and operations

    Provide the data and the first-line scores, and own the actions assigned to them.

  • Finance and data

    Produce customer, product and transaction numbers that agree with the rest of the business.

  • Independent audit

    Examines the adequacy and effectiveness of the policies, controls and procedures (reg 21(1)(c), where appropriate for the firm's size and nature).

The evidence to keep, because reg 18(6) lets the FCA ask for it

  • The current assessment and every earlier version.
  • The information it was based on: data extracts and external sources.
  • The method, with a log of changes and who approved them.
  • The scoring workbook, with control ratings and the evidence for each.
  • Board or committee papers and minutes showing discussion and approval.
  • The action log, with owners, dates and closure evidence.
  • A record of how each national and supervisor input was taken into account.
Up next · Chapter 6Checklist, template and common questions

Chapter 06 · Before you sign it off

Checklist, template and common questions

Use this to test your assessment before the board signs it. Our template gives you the structure and a worked payments example to start from.

3 min read · 1 sections

Translucent blue and lime glass sculpture on a sunlit white concrete terrace above a bay, illustrating financial crime

Our financial crime risk assessment template is a workbook that follows regulation 18(2)(b) and the method in this guide. The payments and e-money edition starts with 32 factors, 13 controls, a heatmap, a dashboard, an action plan and an approval log, and it includes the Brindlemoor Pay worked example used above. Use it as the structure. The content, scores and evidence must be your own.

Is your assessment ready? Tick off what you have

Tick each item you can evidence. Your ticks stay in this browser only.

0%0 of 12

Questions for your board

  • Could another firm have written our risk statements, or are they about us?
  • Which of our five groups has the weakest evidence, and what are we doing about it?
  • Which controls are rated good or strong without testing?
  • What would change our highest residual score, and have we acted on it?
  • When did the board last challenge the assessment, and is it minuted?
  • What have we launched or changed since the last review that this assessment does not cover?

Questions people ask

Is a business-wide risk assessment a legal requirement?

Yes. Regulation 18 of the MLRs requires relevant persons to identify and assess the money laundering and terrorist financing risks their business faces, and to keep a written record. Regulation 18A adds proliferation financing. The FCA's page says: "Central to meeting your AML obligations is a risk assessment of your firm's business."

How often should we review it?

The MLRs do not fix an interval. They require an up-to-date record. The FCA's good practice was a formal annual assessment, and our template recommends at least yearly plus a review when something material changes.

Can a small firm keep it short?

Yes. Regulation 18(3) says the steps should fit the size and nature of the business. A smaller firm can use fewer factors and a lighter process, but it still needs a written assessment that is about its own business.

Do we need a separate proliferation financing assessment?

Regulation 18A requires you to identify and assess proliferation financing risk, with an up-to-date written record. You can keep it as a clearly labelled part of the same document, as our template does. The FCA noted that some assessments focused on fraud and generic risks, often ignoring proliferation financing.

Who supervises us for AML?

The FCA supervises e-money institutions, registered account information service providers and authorised payment institutions other than those that only provide money remittance. HMRC supervises payment institutions that only provide money remittance. Where a firm provides money remittance and other services, the FCA and HMRC decide case by case which of them supervises it (Approach Document 12.22 and 12.23).

Can we use a template?

Yes, as a structure. The FCA's finding was that few firms tailor the assessment to their business, so a template filled with generic wording will not be enough. Replace every example with your own data.

You have reached the endSee the sources

Where this comes from

Sources

Every number and rule in this guide comes from these pages. Check them before you rely on anything, as rules change.

  1. Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 18 (risk assessment)
  2. Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 18A (proliferation financing)
  3. Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 19 (policies, controls and procedures)
  4. Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 21 (internal controls)
  5. Money Laundering Regulations 2017, regulation 33 (enhanced due diligence)
  6. The Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing (Amendment) Regulations 2026 (SI 2026/621)
  7. HM Treasury: National risk assessment of money laundering and terrorist financing 2025 (July 2025)
  8. FCA: Risk assessment processes and controls in firms, our findings (11 November 2025)
  9. FCA: Money laundering regulations
  10. FCA Handbook, Financial Crime Guide FCG 2.2: Governance, culture and information sharing
  11. FCA: Payment Services and Electronic Money, Our Approach (May 2026, version 8), chapter 12
  12. MEMA: Financial crime risk assessment template (reviewed 30 October 2026)

This guide is general information, not legal or regulatory advice. Rules and FCA expectations change; check the sources and take advice on your firm's circumstances.

Free PDF guide

Business-wide risk assessment under MLR 2017

Tell us where to send it. You get the PDF straight away and a copy of the link by email.

We use your details to send the guide and add you to our contacts. See our privacy policy.