Transparency is fundamental in the financial industry. Recent events involving Kristo Käärmann, the CEO of Wise plc, highlight the serious consequences of neglecting regulatory obligations. This incident serves as a reminder for both newly regulated and unregulated financial firms about the importance of timely and appropriate disclosure to regulators.

What Happened?

• HMRC Fine: In February 2021, Kristo Käärmann was fined £365,651 by HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) for deliberately failing to notify them of a capital gains tax liability after selling shares worth £10 million in 2017.
• Public Tax Defaulter Listing: In September 2021, HMRC added Mr Käärmann to their public list of tax defaulters, bringing the matter into the public domain.
• FCA Action: On 28 October 2024, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) fined Mr Käärmann £350,000 for breaching a senior manager conduct rule by failing to disclose this significant tax issue to the FCA in a timely manner.

Regulations Breached

• Senior Manager Conduct Rule 4: This rule requires senior managers to "disclose appropriately any information of which the FCA would reasonably expect notice." Mr Käärmann's failure to inform the FCA about his tax issues for over seven months was a breach of this rule.

Analysis

• Significance of the Breach: As the CEO of a prominent financial firm, Mr Käärmann was expected to uphold high standards of integrity and transparency.
• Impact on Fitness and Propriety: The FCA assesses the suitability of individuals in senior positions. Undisclosed tax issues, especially involving deliberate non-compliance, raise serious concerns about an individual's honesty.
• Regulatory Expectations: The FCA expects prompt self-reporting of matters that could affect a senior manager's suitability, including personal financial issues that may impact their reputation or that of their firm.

Key Takeaways for Firms

1. Timely Disclosure is Essential: Senior managers must promptly disclose significant issues to the FCA, particularly those affecting their fitness and propriety.
2. Understanding Regulatory Obligations: Firms should ensure their senior managers are fully aware of their responsibilities under the FCA's Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR).
3. Promoting a Compliance Culture: Establish a culture where compliance is prioritised, and potential issues are communicated promptly and transparently.

What Firms Need to Be Aware Of

• Regulatory Scrutiny: The FCA closely monitors the conduct of senior managers. Non-compliance can result in substantial fines and reputational damage.
• Personal Conduct Matters: Personal financial issues can have professional implications, especially for individuals in significant positions.
• Firm Responsibility: Organisations must have systems to support their senior managers in meeting regulatory obligations.

How MEMA Consultants Can Assist

At MEMA Consultants, we help firms navigate regulatory complexities:

• Compliance Training: Equip your team with knowledge of FCA regulations and conduct rules.
• Risk Management: Identify and mitigate potential compliance risks within your organisation.
• Policy Development: Assist in creating robust policies that encourage transparency and timely disclosure.

Conclusion

The case of Kristo Käärmann highlights the importance of adhering to regulatory obligations. By fostering a culture of compliance and transparency, firms can avoid similar issues. Contact MEMA Consultants to ensure your firm meets all regulatory requirements and upholds high standards of integrity.

‍